There has been a flurry of blogging (with accompanying comments) recently, on various sites, sparked at least in part by commentary written by Nicholas Riley and John Gruber (Daring Fireball).
The following was originally a comment I left on Steven Frank’s blog under an entry he wrote (‘Zing’), in response to Gruber’s rant (‘That Finder Thing’). And just to be clear, John has some good points, but I think holding up the classic Mac OS Finder as the ultimate goal in any new UI design would be a mistake. People have been mistaking What They’re Used To for What Usability Should Be.
My rant
As far as that article goes, I’m afraid whatever valid points he might have are completely obscured by hyperbolic naysaying and pedantic ranting. And as far as his ‘solutions’ go…
Non-pedant OS 9 holdouts are holding out because they can’t afford/don’t want to upgrade their hardware, or their software hasn’t been upgraded yet, not because of Spatial Orientation. He wants to ditch the columns because they don’t fit into his spatial paradigm? All right, but, having ‘solved’ that problem, he wants to have either an entirely different application to add columns back in, or simply add columns back in to the Finder. What th—-?
In every other Application but the old Finder, Command-N creates a new window. A cardinal rule would be broken by not making a new folder something other than Command-N.
In his anti-NeXT rant, he mentions iTunes and iMovie versus iPhoto and iCal, completely missing the fact that the former pair are on their 3rd and 2nd iterations, while the latter are still 1.x releases. Does he not remember how funky iMovie 1 was? I sure as heck do. iCal sucks right now. Wait a couple of versions and get back to us.
Look, I’ve been using Macs since 1986. I have been using Mac OS X since the Public Beta. With a short adjustment period, I was able to function as fast or faster in OS X. With every new release, the OS has sped up from keeping up with me to being ready for me, and surpasses what OS 9 once was. Enhancements, both UI and otherwise, have been added apace with this operating system, giving me every confidence that they will continue to happen. And without system lockups and rogue programs eating memory, I am an order of magnitude more productive on this OS.
The article’s final shot?
‘Doable? Certainly. But I’m not holding my breath.’
Yes, he couldn’t do that and expel all the hot air necessary for his rants, could he? ;) Seriously, though, I exhaled a long time back and have loved breathing in this OS every day since.
Are there problems with it? Sure! Point me at one that doesn’t have some. Is it getting better all the time? Yes!
Can we do without feedback, both positive and negative? No way! Can we do without bitterness, name calling, and blind pedantry? I can. I hope the Fireball dares to as well.